Are Truffles Worth The Price For The Home Cook?
Truffles are the world's most expensive food item, coming up to even $1600 per pound, but are truffles worth the price? I spent over $300 on fresh black truffles and other truffle products to compare them and see if fresh truffles are really worth the hype, or if there's a cheaper alternative that's just as good or even better.
"Where can I get truffles?" "Are truffles worth the price?" "What can I make with truffles?" "What's the best truffle substitute?" If you've ever googled any of those questions, you're in luck. I did all the heavy lifting to help you make an informed choice and level up everyday dishes like this old-fashioned mac and cheese!
Jump to:
Method of Comparison and Testing
I compared 2 fresh truffles (purchased from different retailers) and 5 other truffle products - truffle zest, truffle salt, preserved whole truffles, truffle oil, and truffle pâté. Eggs were used for comparison since they don't have an inherently strong flavor that would distract from the anticipated delicate flavor of truffle.
- A teaspoon of each fresh truffle and a ¼ teaspoon of each truffle product was added to the scrambled eggs immediately after cooking.
- All scrambled eggs were cooked over medium heat with unsalted butter and salt.
- A teaspoon of each grated truffle was used for topping, and a ¼ teaspoon of each truffle product.
- Each product was noted for its aroma, flavor, and texture.
Analysis of Fresh Truffles
I purchased fresh black winter truffles from 2 retailers - Sabatino Truffles and Urbani Truffles. Since truffle flavor depends heavily on quality, and it was my first time trying fresh truffle, I compared 2 different retailers to get a better understanding of what truffles "should" taste like and to test if the flavor intensity varied with the source.
1. Fresh Black Winter Truffle #1
Cost & Retailer. $110.49 (including taxes & next-day shipping) from Sabatino Truffles.
Aroma. Robust earthiness with sweet, jam-like notes and a faint garlicky aroma. I could smell this truffle before opening the vacuum-sealed package.
Texture and appearance. Rough and firm, with little give when squeezed. It came whole, sliced, and grated easily.
Flavor. The scrambled eggs did not have any perceptible additional flavor after grating the fresh truffle onto the eggs. I added an additional teaspoon of grated truffle and still did not taste a difference.
On shaving, I was able to taste an extremely subtle, earthy, nutty flavor (much like a mushroom). I did not taste any sweet or jam-like notes.
2. Fresh Black Winter Truffle #2
Cost. $130.99 (including taxes & next-day shipping) from Urbani Truffles.
Aroma. Slightly less pungent than the Sabatino truffle with a more potent earthy aroma. It also had a jam-like smell, but less than the Sabatino truffle.
Texture & Appearance. Rough and firm with smaller bumps than the Sabatino truffle.
Flavor. The truffle flavor was extremely subtle and easy to miss if you weren't searching for it. It tasted mainly earthy. I didn't get any sweet notes with this Urbani truffle, just as with the Sabatino truffle.
There was no perceptible difference in flavor between the grated and shaved truffle options.
Analysis of Truffle Products
1. Truffle Zest
Cost. This Sabatino truffle zest seasoning cost $14.95 on Amazon.
Aroma. The truffle zest was extremely aromatic, and I could immediately smell it once I broke the seal, but it was not overpowering or unpleasant. It has deep, earthy notes with a sweet, chocolate-like component likely due to carob powder as the first ingredient.
Texture & Appearance. The seasoning is ground finely into a brown-colored dust resembling cocoa powder. If your dish is still hot or has any moisture, it blends in a little bit. It doesn't have a gritty mouthfeel.
Flavor. The aroma translated to an identical flavor on the scrambled eggs. It had a clear "truffle" flavor with subtle sweetness. This truffle zest had an almost identical flavor to the truffle dishes I've most enjoyed at my favorite restaurants. This was my favorite.
2. Truffle Salt
Cost. This Cassina Rossa truffle salt cost $22.99 on Amazon.
Aroma. The truffle salt had an overwhelmingly pungent truffle aroma that leaned mostly savory and smelled very artificial.
Texture & Appearance. The salt was coarse with visible black flecks (presumably black summer truffle, a listed ingredient).
Flavor. Truffle salt replaced an identical amount of salt used in the other eggs. The scrambled eggs had a subtle but clear truffle flavor and didn't have any artificial taste, as I had anticipated. I could stand a little more truffle flavor, but adding any more of the truffle salt would have made the eggs too salty.
3. Preserved Whole Truffles
Cost. I got Gourmanity whole preserved black truffles on Amazon for $22.99.
Aroma. The preserved truffles had an earthy aroma with a mild chocolatey layer. The aroma was generally muted compared to the other truffle products and the fresh truffle itself. It also had a "jarlic" smell.
Texture & Appearance. The jar had 4 small whole truffles in brine. They were firm but had a little more give than the fresh truffles. They did have a gritty texture that I didn't like very much.
Flavor. Had decent flavor on the scrambled eggs that was mostly earthy - the chocolatey aromatic notes did not translate into the taste. Adding more grated truffle made the "jarred garlic" taste more potent, which I found off-putting.
4. Truffle Oil
Cost. I purchased the truffle oil from my local grocery store for $15.49. The same Monini black truffle oil is available on Amazon, but it's a little more expensive.
Aroma. The oil didn't have any truffle aroma and smelled subtly of olive oil.
Texture & Appearance. It looked like regular olive oil. There were no obvious signs of truffle, such as grated/shaved pieces or flecks.
Flavor. Although there was a subtle truffle flavor, the primary flavor was olive oil, and the truffle flavor taste was obviously artificial, much like ripe fresh banana flavor vs artificial banana extract flavor.
5. Truffle Pâté
Cost. I used this La Rustichella black truffle paté. It was $20.99 on Amazon.
Aroma. The paté had a very faint truffle aroma but mostly smelled like "jarlic," so the smell wasn't as pleasant as some of the other truffle products.
Texture & Appearance. The paté wasn't smooth; it resembled caviar.
Flavor. The truffle flavor was only barely perceptible on the scrambled eggs, and the taste was overpowered by a "jarlic" flavor that made eating it very unpleasant.
It's also worth noting that the first 2 ingredients listed on the paté label were mushrooms, so this product did not have much actual truffle or truffle flavoring included.
Conclusion & My Top Truffle Recommendation
So are fresh truffles worth the price? Most likely not for the home cook. Generally, the flavor of truffles degrades quickly with time, so the clock starts ticking once you order them.
In addition, many restaurants enhance their truffle dishes with truffle flavoring because real truffle flavor is extremely subtle and easy to miss, so you'll likely be disappointed after forking out all that cash.
Sabatino Truffle Zest
If you're looking to recreate a flavor you've had in a restaurant, this Sabatino truffle zest is the best option. It's my top pick, above the real deal! It's economical and has a clear yet delicate "truffle" flavor with some nuanced sweet notes.
I used it to recreate a beautiful truffle whipped ricotta I had at a restaurant, and the flavor was identical!
Other Recommended Truffle Products
Truffle Salt
Photo Credit: amazon.com
This Casina Rossa truffle salt is a close second. It has a nice flavor that also isn't artificial; however, you're a little limited in how much truffle flavor you can add since it will also make your dish salty.
Whole Preserved Truffles
Photo Credit: amazon.com
These Gourmanity Tartufi whole black truffles are good if you enjoy a light truffle flavor. If you pile on a lot, you'll start to get a jarred garlic taste that can be off-putting.
Truffle FAQs
Truffles are fungi and cousins to mushrooms, but they grow underground on tree roots (typically oak and hazel trees). They have a distinct earthy aroma that helps them spread their spores by attracting animals, including beetles, deer, and squirrels.
There are 3 varieties - black, white, and burgundy truffles. White truffles are the most expensive and generally have the most delicate flavor.
Mostly, fresh truffles are imported into the US with the most popular supplier of truffles (worldwide) being Urbani Truffles. Sabatino Truffles are another option for regular home cooks looking to purchase fresh truffles at non-commercial volume/pace.
There are other suppliers like Inland Foods; however, since they mostly supply restaurants and retailers, these are only options if you have a commercial food license or other qualifications.
Truffles are extremely difficult to farm successfully since they require a specific climate and soil quality. Plus, once the tree roots are inoculated with the right fungus, it can take 6-10 years for the truffles to be ready for harvest - a long timeline that doesn't allow for easy adjustments to farming techniques.
This explains why Chinese truffles are cheaper since they are mostly harvested prematurely and, as a result, have a much milder aroma and flavor (if any).
When cared for appropriately, fresh truffles can last 6-10 days. The truffle should be wrapped in a fresh piece of paper towel daily to discourage molding. Store it in an airtight container like a mason jar. This short shelf-life is part of the reason truffles may not be worth it for regular home use.
It's ok to cook black truffles since their mild, delicate flavor can be intensified with gentle heat. White truffles, on the other hand, have extremely volatile flavor compounds that are lost when cooked.
Most times, no. Many truffle oil products don't actually include much truffle and instead use an artificial truffle extract. Truffle oils can tend to taste more artificial than other truffle products.
Black truffles are best used in dishes as a finishing touch or during cooking over low to medium heat. Try using grated truffles in appetizers like whipped ricotta, sides like crab mac and cheese, or shaved on top of pizza made with this easy homemade pizza dough.
Ainseanlea's Tips for Cooking With Truffle
- Use truffles as a finisher or during cooking over low heat. Truffles have a volatile flavor compounds that can be lost when exposed to too much heat
- Avoid using truffles in dishes with strong flavors. Since the truffle flavor is delicate, it is best used in simpler dishes for added complexity. Think mac and cheese, scrambled eggs, etc.
- Supplement with a good truffle product. Sabatino truffle zest is my favorite since it has a clear, nuanced truffle flavor without any preservative flavor or added salt.
Try Using Truffle With These Recipes!
Tried out one of these truffle products? Let me know in a comment! I love hearing your feedback and it greatly helps me improve posts for you!
